Swords Against Death Re-Read: “The Howling Tower”

lankhmar 5Bill Ward and I  are re-reading a book from Fritz Leiber’s famous Lankhmar series, Swords Against Death. We hope you’ll pick up a copy and join us. This week we tackled the fifth tale in the volume, “The Howling Tower.”

Howard: In the overall run of Fafhrd and Gray Mouser episodes, this is a filler. That said, it’s a strong one, and holds up much better than, say “The Circle Curse” or even “The Bleak Shore” from last week. Having written to word count limits several times at this point, I couldn’t help feeling that’s what Leiber might have done here. He had a few thousand words worth of room to tell a story, so he kept it short and sweet. Or, possibly, he needed a quick check. Either way, what we got was fairly simple (though that doesn’t mean it wasn’t well executed). Consider the structure: 1. The setup, with the tower and the landscape and the howling. 2. Fafhrd’s disappearance and the Mouser’s pursuit. 3. The Mouser reaches the tower and the villain monologues. 4. The Mouser forces the villain into the nightmare realm with him. 5. The villain gets what’s coming to him.

Bill: I agree, I also noticed how concise the story was. The same basic elements could have gone into a longer story, one that culminated in an otherworldly combat with the spectral hounds, but instead it’s condensed right down into an effective little ghost story.

lakhmar 4Howard: Right! It’s still pretty satisfying. Sure, it isn’t a great one like “Thieves’ House” or some of those coming up, but it fires on full cylinders all the way. The mystery and the danger are well presented, and I was actually afraid for Fafhrd, despite knowing he was going to come out okay. Leiber even makes the monologue work, which is a helluva thing. In lesser hands it would have been much more of an info dump. Leiber almost manages to make that rant completely about character even as the bad guy’s telling us everything we need to know about the setup.

Bill: That struck me as well, learning so much about the villain — and I didn’t even spot it as set up for the end. The description of the killing of the hounds was vivid and chilling and really got my attention. Leiber is very good at that sort of thing.

Howard: He sure is. I didn’t see the scaffolding the first times I read this story — I was quite swept up by it. Now I can wonder how it was done, and under what constraints, and I see that Leiber didn’t have word space or inclination to spread out and deliver a more detailed story. But what he gave us works very well, thank you. I’m glad he gave us more, and pieces that were better developed, but this was enjoyable.

lankhmar 6Bill: Short as it was he still had some time for some wonderful character moments — Fafhrd’s rather poetic invitation to “the wolves” to come share their fire, The Gray Mouser’s repulsion at having so terrified the old madman that he says he would have preferred simply killing him instead. The quick but none-the-less vivid details in the old man’s backstory also give a great explanation for a very common trope — this lone magician living in a haunted tower actually has a whole history leading up to that, all of which makes good sense. Even though it’s a quick story, it provides plenty of memorable images and moments.

Howard: Next week we move on to one I re-read an awful lot, usually right before I’d read the story that follows it, which is a real favorite (“The Seven Black Priests”). On to “The Sunken Land.” Hope to see you here.

4 Comments on “Swords Against Death Re-Read: “The Howling Tower”

  1. Yeah, fun little ghost story. I especially liked the old man’s recounting of his crimes. I remember liking the Mignola/Chaykin adaptation of this one. I’ll have to look it up later and see how it holds up.

    • I just flipped through the Chaykin and Mignola adaption of this last night, and it’s still pretty darned good. Mingnola writes at the end (I have the trader paperback now) that it’s the only work he was involved in before Hellboy that he’s still proud of.

  2. I would join you guys in the re-reading but I read these again not long ago and I don’t want to spoil it for when I do again in a couple of years. Truth is, I can follow along anyway, because I’ve read all the stories several times (except for Adept’s Gambit, the only story I don’t like).

    This story has a great creepy atmosphere and I agree about feeling concern for Fafhrd, as well as feeling Mouser’s concerned. The love of the two companions really comes through in some of these stories, and this is one of them. I also agree that Leiber is great at giving a lot of information without it sounding like simple exposition.

    Looking forward to your discussion of The Sunken Land, one of the best stories. Leiber makes it look so easy, and we writers know it’s not.

  3. At the risk of sounding like a nob, I think I’d call this the first story in the collection that simply feels perfect. The magic is thoroughly explained yet otherworldly and unsettling; the resolution is entirely predictable yet wonderfully exciting; and our nameless sorcerer is a marked improvement on last story’s villain in every-which-way, not in the least because he has a palpable motivation.

    Onto “The Sunken Land”… next week, ’cause I’ve got some Howard and Lovecraft to catch up with. Peace out.

Leave a Reply to RubberLotus Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published.